Page C1.1 . 22 February 2006                     
ArchitectureWeek - Culture Department
< Prev Page Next Page >
  • A Modern More or Less Humane

      Current Contents
      Blog Center
      Download Center
      New Products
      Products Guide
      Classic Home
      Architecture Forum
      Architects Directory
      Topics Library
      Complete Archive
      Web Directory
      About ArchWeek
      Subscribe & Contribute
      Free Newsletters


    [an error occurred while processing this directive]

    A Modern More or Less Humane

    by Joseph E. Pollack

    Since before its completion in 2002, Stephen Holl's award-winning MIT dormitory, Simmons Hall, has been garnering praise from the architectural community. But assessing a building as a professional critic is different from living in and interacting with it. I wondered how the students who lived there felt about it.

    I took advantage of an open house for newly accepted students and joined a tour of the building. We saw the dorm rooms, lounge spaces, and common areas. I was able to interview students who were in the process of selecting a dorm, and I sought out opinions that were unaffected by any training in architecture. Through this informal, unscientific survey, I quickly discovered that the building much praised by critics is as much criticized by those personally involved with it.

    According to his Web site, Holl's intention was to produce a porous structure that would promote free-flowing social activity and energy. The building does indeed seem to be a refreshing change from the material palette, primarily brick, of the surrounding campus. The Simmons Hall facade is covered with hundreds of L-shaped metal panels that frame small square windows. As intended, the building's monolithic form has the appearance of a permeable membrane.

    To seek out lay opinions of the building, I talked to prospective students and their parents. They didn't discuss surface porosity or color composition of the polychromatic windows, but focused instead on the overall "feeling" of the place. One father said, "[The building] just looks way too huge.... I felt like it was going to fall over when we were looking for the entrance and I looked up the front of it.... It seems too big to be comfortable around it."   >>>

    Discuss this article in the Architecture Forum...


    ArchWeek Image

    Simmons Hall, Stephen Holl's award-winning dormitory on the MIT campus, as approached from the southwest.
    Photo: Joseph E. Pollack

    ArchWeek Image

    One of Simmons Hall's many exterior terraces as seen from the street.
    Photo: Joseph E. Pollack


    Click on thumbnail images
    to view full-size pictures.

    < Prev Page Next Page > Send this to a friend       Subscribe       Contribute       Media Kit       Privacy       Comments
    ARCHWEEK   |   GREAT BUILDINGS   |   DISCUSSION   |   NEW BOOKS   |   FREE 3D   |   SEARCH © 2006 Artifice, Inc. - All Rights Reserved